Skip to main content

Rolling Stock Market in Canadian Rail Transit: A Historical Perspective

Introduction

The rolling stock market, particularly for Light Rail Transit (LRT) and tram procurement, has been a dynamic sector in Canadian rail transit over the past 50 years. A detailed look at the procurement patterns in five major Canadian cities—Vancouver, Calgary, Edmonton, Montreal, and Toronto—reveals a significant trend: every second half of each decade has been marked by a surge in procurement activities. This article delves into the data to uncover the historical procurement patterns and their implications for the future of Canadian rail transit.

Vancouver Rolling Stock Market

Vancouver’s procurement history shows a clear pattern of increased activity in the second half of each decade. The city acquired a substantial number of cars for its SkyTrain system during these periods:

– 1984–1986: 114 ICTS Mark I cars
– 1990–1991: 16 ICTS Mark I cars
– 1994–1995: 20 ICTS Mark I cars
– 2000–2002: 60 ART Mark II cars
– 2009: 34 ART Mark II cars
– 2010: 14 ART Mark II cars
– 2016: 28 Innovia Metro Mark III cars
– 2018–2020: 56 Innovia Metro Mark III cars
– 2009: 40 Hyundai Rotem EMU cars
– 2019–2020: 24 Hyundai Rotem EMU cars

Calgary Rolling Stock Market

Calgary has also seen significant procurement activities, particularly in the second half of the decades:

– 1979–1985: 83 Siemens–Duewag U2 cars
– 1988: 2 Siemens–Duewag U2 AC cars
– 2001–2006: 72 Siemens SD-160 Series 5/6/7 cars
– 2007–2012: 38 Siemens SD-160NG Series 8 cars
– 2013–2018: 69 Siemens S200 cars

Edmonton Rolling Stock Market

Edmonton’s rolling stock procurement has followed a similar pattern:

– 1977: 37 Siemens-Duewag U2 (RTE 1) cars
– 1980: 3 Siemens-Duewag U2 (RTE 1) cars
– 1983: 20 Siemens-Duewag U2 (RTE 1) cars
– 2005: 37 Siemens SD-160 cars
– 2010: 20 Siemens SD-160 cars
– 2018: 26 Bombardier/Alstom Flexity Freedom cars
– 2021: 46 Hyundai Rotem LRV cars

Montreal Rolling Stock Market

Montreal has consistently updated its fleet, particularly in the second half of the decades:

– 1965–1967: 336 MR-63 cars
– 1976–1980: 360 MR-73 cars
– 2015–2021: 639 MPM-10 “Azur” cars

Toronto Rolling Stock

Toronto’s procurement history is extensive, reflecting a robust rolling stock market:

– 1953–1954: 100 GRC&WG G-1 cars
– 1995–2001: 372 BT RTC-75 T-1 cars
– 1954–1955: 6 GRC&WG G-2 cars
– 1958–1959: 6 GRC&WG G-4 cars
– 1956: 28 GRC&WG G-3 cars
– 1962–1963: 36 MLW M-1 cars
– 1965–1966: 164 HSC RTC-75 H-1 cars
– 1971: 76 HSC RTC-75 H-2 cars
– 1974–1975: 88 HSC RTC-75 H-4 cars
– 1976–1979: 138 HSC RTC-75 H-5 cars
– 1986–1989: 126 UTDC RTC-75 H-6 cars
– 2009–2015: 480 Toronto Rocket cars
– 1921–1954: 250 Peter Witt cars
– 1922–1965: 100 Peter Witt cars
– 1921–1938: 60 2-door trailers
– 1923–1954: 165 3-door trailers
– 1938–1971: 317 PCC (Air-electric) cars
– 1947–1995: 428 PCC (All-electric) cars
– 1979–2019: 196 CLRV cars
– 1988–2019: 52 ALRV cars
– 2014–present: 204 Flexity Outlook cars

Réseau express métropolitain (REM) 

The REM project in Montreal is a recent addition to the city’s transit infrastructure, with significant procurement in the past few years:

– 2018–2023: 212 Alstom Metropolis cars

Canadian Rail Transit Rolling Stock Orders

City Car Model Year Manufactured Quantity Order Number(s)
Vancouver
  ICTS Mark I 1984–1986 114 001–056; 061–118
  ICTS Mark I 1990–1991 16 121–136
  ICTS Mark I 1994–1995 20 137–156
  ART Mark II 2000–2002 60 201–260
  ART Mark II 2009 34 301–334
  ART Mark II 2010 14 335–348
  Innovia Metro Mark III 2016 28 401–428
  Innovia Metro Mark III 2018–2020 56 429–484
  Hyundai Rotem EMU 2009 40 101–120; 201–220
  Hyundai Rotem EMU 2019–2020 24 121–132; 221–232
Calgary
  Siemens–Duewag U2 1979–1985 83 2001–2083, 2090
  Siemens–Duewag U2 AC 1988 2 2101–2102
  Siemens SD-160 Series 5/6/7 2001–2006 72 2201–2272
  Siemens SD-160NG Series 8 2007–2012 38 2301–2338
  Siemens S200 2013–2018 69 2401–2469
Edmonton
  Siemens-Duewag U2 (RTE 1) 1977 37 1001–1014
  Siemens-Duewag U2 (RTE 1) 1980 3 1015–1017
  Siemens-Duewag U2 (RTE 1) 1983 20 1018–1037
  Siemens SD-160 2005 37 1038–1074
  Siemens SD-160 2010 20 1075–1094
  Bombardier/Alstom Flexity Freedom 2018 26 2001–2026
  Hyundai Rotem LRV 2021 46 N/A
Toronto
  GRC&WG G-1 1953–1954 100 5000–5099
  BT RTC-75 T-1 1995–2001 372 5000–5371
  GRC&WG G-2 1954–1955 6 5100–5105
  GRC&WG G-4 1958–1959 6 5110–5115
  GRC&WG G-3 1956 28 5200–5227
  MLW M-1 1962–1963 36 5300–5335
  HSC RTC-75 H-1 1965–1966 164 5336–5499
  HSC RTC-75 H-2 1971 76 5500–5575
  HSC RTC-75 H-4 1974–1975 88 5576–5663
  HSC RTC-75 H-5 1976–1979 138 5670–5807
  UTDC RTC-75 H-6 1986–1989 126 5810–5935
  Toronto Rocket 2009–2015 480 6131–6136; 6141/2/5/6; 6191/2/5/6
  Peter Witt 1921–1954 250 N/A
  Peter Witt 1922–1965 100 N/A
  Flexity Outlook 2009 204 N/A
Montreal
  MR-63 1966 369 N/A
  MR-73 1976 423 N/A
  MR-83 1980 171 N/A
  MR-90 1990 140 N/A
  AZUR 2016 468 N/A
  REM – Alstom Metropolis 2018–2023 212 N/A

Canadian Rail Transit Rolling Stock Orders Over Time

Canadian Rail Transit Rolling Stock Orders Over Time
Canadian Rail Transit Rolling Stock Orders

Canadian Rail Transit Rolling Stock Orders Every 5 Years

Canadian Rail Transit Rolling Stock Orders Every 5 Years

Conclusion

The data clearly indicates that every second half of each decade has been a peak period for rolling stock procurement in Canada’s major cities. This pattern suggests that procurement cycles are influenced by various factors, including technological advancements, population growth, and economic conditions.

Rolling stock procurement is often a sub-project of broader development and extension line projects, as well as part of asset management strategies. The observed trend shows that the first half of each decade is typically dedicated to the design and planning of civil works and system engineering by federal and municipal authorities. Consequently, the golden window for procurement and implementation tends to fall in the second half of each decade.

The 1990s was an exception to this trend. The combination of economic challenges, fiscal policies, and the aging of existing infrastructure contributed to a slower pace of infrastructure development in Canada during this period. These factors collectively resulted in fewer procurement activities compared to other decades.

Understanding these trends is crucial for future planning and investment in Canadian rail transit. As cities continue to expand and modernize their transit systems, the rolling stock market will remain a vital component of urban mobility, shaping the way Canadians commute and travel within their cities.

Rolling Stock Market in Canadian Rail Transit: A Historical Perspective

The Pulse of Canadian Transit

A 50-Year Journey of Rolling Stock Procurement and Planning

An Engine of Change: A Historical Timeline

1950s-1970s: The Urban Rail Dawn

The post-war era saw Canadian cities begin to invest heavily in modern urban transit. The shift from diesel buses to electric rail systems began, with Montreal and Toronto opening their foundational subway lines. Early rolling stock was characterized by heavy, durable steel construction, setting the stage for future expansion.

1980s: The Light Rail Transit (LRT) Boom

A new wave of transit development brought LRT systems to western Canada. Cities like Edmonton and Calgary adopted proven European tram technology, leading to significant procurement of vehicles like the Siemens-Duewag U2. This decade was defined by expansion and the adoption of standardized, efficient light rail vehicles.

1990s: A Period of Economic Constraint

Compared to other decades, the 90s saw a marked slowdown in new procurement activities. A combination of economic recession and shifts in government fiscal policy led to deferred capital projects. Transit agencies focused more on maintaining aging fleets rather than large-scale expansion, making this a notable exception in the procurement cycle.

2000s-Present: Modernization and Sustainability

The new millennium ushered in an era of technological advancement and a renewed focus on sustainable urban mobility. Procurements now emphasize energy efficiency, accessibility, and passenger comfort, with advanced systems like Alstom's Citadis and Siemens' S70 series becoming commonplace. International partnerships have become crucial in delivering these next-generation fleets.

The Rhythm of Procurement

Analysis reveals a consistent cycle: the first half of each decade is for planning and design, while the second half sees a surge in rolling stock orders. This chart visualizes the total units ordered across major Canadian cities in five-year intervals, highlighting this powerful trend.

Market Landscape

The Canadian market features several key international manufacturers. Alstom (following its acquisition of Bombardier) holds a significant share, alongside major players like Siemens and Hyundai Rotem, who have secured key contracts for large urban projects.

A Tale of Five Cities

Over the last 50 years, Canada's largest cities have been the epicenters of transit investment. This chart compares the total rolling stock units procured by each city, reflecting their long-term commitment to expanding and modernizing their rail networks.

Recent Landmark Procurements

212

Montreal REM

76

Toronto Eglinton Crosstown

84

Vancouver Broadway & Mark III

63

Calgary SD160NG

On the Right Track: Future Directions

Data-Driven Planning

Understanding historical procurement cycles is crucial for proactive planning. By anticipating the "golden window" for procurement in the latter half of each decade, transit authorities and manufacturers can better align their financial, engineering, and production timelines to ensure smoother project delivery and cost efficiency.

Sustainability and Innovation

Future fleets must align with ambitious climate goals. This means prioritizing procurement of energy-efficient, low-emission vehicles. Furthermore, leveraging technological innovations such as predictive maintenance systems and enhanced digital passenger amenities will be key to maximizing fleet longevity and improving the rider experience.

Infographic based on the research paper "Rolling Stock Market in Canadian Rail Transit: A Historical Perspective" by Danial Faraji, Jeremie Huet, and Heather Kruger.